Reality shows and text messaging: the future of giving?

By Erin Shaver, JVA Associate

Not sure how many of you watch “American Idol” out there, but we’re guessing from the show’s ratings it may be quite a few. Because we have some watchers here at JVA, we know that the pop culture phenomenon is airing its second annual Idol Gives Backprogram April 9.

Sure, it can be overhyped and somewhat self-congratulatory, but last year, “Idol” raised over $76 million for charity. This year, producers are hoping for an even bigger payout, announcing such stars as Bono, Brad Pitt, Reese Witherspoon, Peyton and Eli Manning, and this year’s presidential candidates to support six major nonprofits: the Children’s Defense Fund; The Global Fund; Make It Right; Malaria No More; Save The Children, U.S. Programs; and the Children’s Health Fund.

Regardless of whether you are amused by Simon Cowell’s insults or even know who won last season, one must take heed on both the sheer dollars raised from these types of events and the significant awareness it brings these charities to be in front of hundreds of millions of people in a slick Hollywood production.

In fact, using major pop culture events—especially youth-oriented ones like “Idol”—to raise money for good causes seems to be a pretty successful and recent trend. In February, Denver-based Mobile Accord helped the United Way launch the first text-to-give commercial spot in the U.S. during the Super Bowl, raising $30,000 for United Way’s youth fitness programs in only 10 seconds from $5 text message gifts. Mobile Accord thinks that mobile giving is the next big wave for nonprofits; kind of the way having a Web site and with an online giving system has become the standard over the last five to 10 years.

We attended a recent Black Tie Colorado event in which Mobile Accord, a past client of JVA’s, presented its massive launch plan to bring mobile giving to all nonprofits, with local Colorado organizations on the cutting edge. In mid-May 2008, it plans to launch a Web site to make its mobile giving service available to all nonprofits—NPOs can sign up, pay a one-time activation fee, select their code (like a url) and, after being approved as an eligible 501(c)(3), can start the service. Mobile Accord’s new Web site will track activity and issue reports on its text donation activity, its foundation arm will issue the funds on a monthly basis, and, best of all, it says that all wireless carriers are on board and have agreed not to take a penny from the donation (Mobile Accord takes a 10% commission).

While it may not be great for every organization, those that plan big events would be prime candidates to use the service to get the most out of the spontaneous, impulsive give that can often happen when endorphins are running high and everyone feels rallied around a cause. While “Idol Gives Back,” being a TV show, can capitalize on these moments of emotion and connection more easily (phone lines and Internet are usually at viewers’ easy disposal), the text-to-give idea seems like an interesting proposition for NPOs that host charitable festivals, concerts or races, where an attendee’s moment of passionate altruism may or may not carry over into a donation when he or she gets home to his/her computer or checkbook.

Nonprofits are already turning more and more to social networking sites to publicize their cause through Facebook’s Causes application and MySpace’s Impact application (“Idol’s” MySpace url is While to some degree they are relinquishing control over the messaging (and it’s unclear how much of an increase in donations they receive as a result), they are able to get their name and cause in front of more people (mostly young) through the viral spread of social networking without a lot of resources expended. Text-to-give takes it one step further; not only using the tools of young people to get their organization out there, but also to receive the benefit of a new donor.

So we’ll probably be watching “Idol Gives Back” this week, and likewise we will keep our eye on Mobile Accord’s new plans. Every generation has its own giving strategy, and we know from many studies that young people already prefer to give online over more traditional means.

With the popularity of reality shows, social networking and text messaging seeming here to stay for the younger set, at least for a while, star-studded and slickly produced events like “Idol Gives Back” and the successes of big Super Bowl-sized text-to-give campaigns cannot be ignored. The trends will trickle down to the smaller folks, and in mobile giving’s case, may already be taking off in Colorado in just a few short months

What do you think? If this topic interests you, we’d like to know! Please answer our quick (four-question) survey!

This entry was posted in Commentary and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Reality shows and text messaging: the future of giving?

  1. Oprah says:

    I think if you’re talking about reality shows you missed the boat since you didn’t talk about Oprah’s Big Give. Now there’s an idea that really seems to make fundraising accessible to everyone by inspiring us to think about how we can help our neighbors and organizations in our communities with our time and energy (and money to back it.)

    Texting is fine and a good component for certain situations and organizations, but it’s a lot like online giving. It’s not the panacea that everyone thought it would be a few years ago. Just because you have the capacity to receive online gifts, or text gift, doesn’t mean you are going to get them. It’s still going to be a lot of marketing and communicating of your mission and we all know that is best done through dedicated volunteers who are excited to be part of your work.

  2. Pingback: Do you Razoo? « JVA Consulting’s Weblog

JVA welcomes your comments and feedback on all Nonprofit Street articles. While JVA will post all relevant comments, it will not post comments that are advertising products or services or those with obscenities. Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s